We had a five night stay at Yellowcraig a couple of weeks ago and found it to be a lovely site, well presented and maintained by friendly staff. The facilities are very good too, maybe a touch dated but superbly clean as is the whole site. It was a memorable stay with easy beach access and good walks all around. Our only complaint was noisy dogs which were not under proper control... a team of three Akitas, one of which whimpered and whined constantly for attention and a couple of Labradors which barked for attention if they weren't included in family activities. This is not in any way a complaint against dogs, there were plenty of others which were no bother at all but it is a complaint against owners who do not consider other members who go away for a quiet and peaceful stay in the countryside. It would be a help if the site wardens were able to keep a closer eye on this situation on all sites, after all it is a condition of the club site rules.